JG's blog

We all told you so! As usual the Government didn't listen

No prizes for guessing what the papers are full of today.  The slow motion car crash that has been in the making for many, many months now has finally made impact - though not entirely in the manner predicted nor has the crashing car come to halt yet.  Yesterday the Home Improvement Packs (HIPs) fiasco finally came to a head.  The watered down, un-necessary, unwanted scheme that has been doomed to fail from the start has failed before they even started!  As reported yesterday, the scheme has been put back by two months until the start of August.  They have also been watered down even furthe

Blair Force One ready for launch

Blair Force One is ready for launch. In fact, both of them are. Our outgoing PM has finally sanctioned the purchase of over £100m worth of aircrafts so that his best buddy Gordon and the Queen don't have to mix with the hoi polloi when doing "business" all over the globe. So much for global warming (though it has long been Government policy to exclude aviation from the environment debate - another runway at Heathrow anyone?).

Public sector reform has failed us all

As the Blair era comes to and end, there is and has already been much reflection on the past 10 years. Reform was always at the top of the New Labour agenda way back when before 1997. It was greeted with cheers and provided hope to the masses. Unfortunately, the reality is where New Labour say reform read unwanted, poorly thought out, unneeded meddling.

Review of the Papers, Wednesday 23 May

The government's policy on reforming the housing market was thrown into disarray last night as the communities secretary, Ruth Kelly, was forced into a last-minute retreat over the controversial introduction of home information packs. The packs, which were due to come into force next week to accompany every property sale, have been postponed until August 1 and at first will be introduced only for four-bedroom or larger houses - less than 20% of the market.

HIPs to be delayed?

It is being reported on the BBC that the introduction of the Home Improvement Packs will be delayed. DCLG Secretary, Ruth Kelly, is expected to make an annoucement... more later...

UPDATE:  The introduction of HIPs has been put back 2 months and they will now be introduced on 1st August.

Hard luck Metronet

Metronet, the consortium who are currently cocking up the upgrade of much of the London Underground system, are looking to take £600m of public money to cover their over-running costs.  The extremely complicated PPP contract that was signed to last 30 years has so far cost Metronet £1.2bn in overspend.  Mayor Ken Livingston has always been a strong opponent of the deal and has publicly stated that they will not receive a penny if he has anything to do with it.  And good for him.  Balfour Beatty, Bombardier, Thames Water, EDF Energy and Atkins - you signed this contract and you probably thou

Tax credits costing billions

What exactly is the point in the tax credit system?  It seems to me just a way of confusing the tax system as much as possible so that people are so baffled they mess up their claims for what is rightfully, under the system, theirs.  The system is also so complex that it makes it much more viable to fraud and also costs an unnecessary amount of money to administrate.  There is little doubt that the scheme is haemorrhaging money due to fraud and admin - the Lib Dems claim that it has cost more than an incredible £9bn in its first three years - 50% more than previous estimates.  Revenue &

Would you like an ipod with that underserved bonus?

The department described by outgoing Secretary of State John Reid as "not fit for purpose" is paying out £3.6m in bonuses to its staff. The Home Office, which has recently been split up as it could not cope with the work load, feel one in five of its civil servants deserves a bonus of up to £15k. This despite scandals such as the release of 1000 foreign criminals who should have been deported. This is a massive 75% increase since 2002, begging the questions - have things really got better (75% better!) since 2002? What exactly are these people being rewarded for?

Review of the Papers, Tuesday 22 May

The government's tax credit scheme was branded "a shambles" yesterday after it was alleged that the cost of fraud and poor administration was likely to be more than £9bn in its first three years - 50% more than previous estimates.

http://business.guardian.co.uk/story/0,,2085124,00.html

Government moves to liberalise the planning system, from domestic conservatories to nuclear power stations, were hailed by business leaders and excoriated by environmentalists last night.

http://society.guardian.co.uk/communities/story/0,,2085174,00.html

Twenty top civil servants in the Home Office have been given top of the range iPods to provide them with lessons in leadership. In a pilot scheme the department has spent almost £9,000 on the gadgets as part of a “constant” way of finding new means to give staff training. Home Office officials were last night bracing themselves for a barrage of criticism over the purchase which was described by one source as “a wacky idea”.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article1821555.ece

The first high profile causalty of the NHS online recruitment fiasco

The first high profile casualty of the NHS online recruitment fiasco has hit.  The chairman of the British Medical Association, James Johnson, has resigned after he was accused of being too close to the Government on the issue.  Mr Johnson, speaking to the Guardian, said "I appear to have lost the confidence of my council largely over a letter ... expressing some support for the chief medical officer, who is being blamed for what has happened.

Review of the Papers, Monday 21 May

The chairman of the British Medical Association, James Johnson, resigned suddenly last night over accusations that he was siding with the government in the debacle over training jobs for junior doctors. Mr Johnson said the criticism of him had "got very nasty" and he felt he had lost the confidence of some of his colleagues. His decision to quit made him the highest profile casualty so far in the increasingly heated row between ministers and doctors, which has seen white-coat protest marches in Whitehall and an apology for the fiasco by the health secretary, Patricia Hewitt.

Michael Portillo: "Gordon is going to meddle"

£10bn of IT projects a year are not successful

The government can not do IT projects.  Not a revelation to regular readers of Picking Losers, but even civil servants are now accepting the hard facts.  Joe Harley, chief information officer and the official in charge of IT at the Department for Work and Pensions has said that only 30% of Government IT projects are successful.  Given this incredibly low success rate, it is worrying to know that public sector IT costs £14bn a year, equivalent to 75 hospitals.  That is to say, we are wasting £10bn a year on public IT systems that do not meet the criteria to even be considered successful - re

The 10 year rule

What makes Gordon Brown think that he can effectively steal? He is set to launch an initiative to raid dormant accounts to raise £300m. OK, the money will be put to what the Lottery commission believe are "good causes", but I still don't think that justifies him assuming he has a right to do this. Has it got anything to do with the ever rising Olympic costs and him needing to find new and "innovative" ways to get money of us? Let's face it, he has just about pulled every other trick in the book and made up a few more himself.

Only the Government's complete incompetence can save us now

Ahh!  You couldn't make this one up.  Home Improvement Packs.  The Tories have tried to stop them.  The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors has tried to stop them.  In fact the whole property industry pretty much has tried to stop them.  Even Ruth Kelly has tried to stop them and it's her department!  Where all others have failed, the Government's complete incompetence with IT systems may yet come to the rescue.  According to the Times

DoH had no choice, it wasn't a belated good decision

Yesterday I asked the question, was the DoH decision to scrap the NHS online recruitment system a belated good decision or the only option left? Andrew Rowland, vice-chairman of the BMA's junior doctors committee, rather surprisingly believes "The Department of Health has at last seen sense and effectively abandoned the unfair, discredited and shambolic MTAS system." I couldn't disagree more.

Judicial review of HIPs?

With just a couple of weeks to go before the introduction of the Home Improvement Packs, The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) has thrown a spanner in to the Government's works.  Fearing a housing market crash from the combined effect of potential sellers being put of selling due to HIPs, a rush of sales prior to the 1st June and rising interest rates, RICS are now seeking a judicial review over the packs.  They are claiming, what we all know, that there aren't enough inspectors and also that the consultation process was not carried out properly.  They did, however, fail to add that the packs are a waste of time and money.

The new poll: The Railways

A slender majority of people wanted to see the NHS retain political control by the government. Maybe a poll asking whether the NHS should be taken away from nationalisation completely would have produced a different result? One for the future maybe...

A new poll has started and is likely to cause some debate - it already has with myself and bgp. Is the solution to the railways to:

a) Renationalise them

You are under arrest for possession of an egg with intent to throw

If ever proof were needed that the more the government intervene the more damage they actually do here it is. The government think that the best way to improve policing is tell the policemen exactly how to their job. This has led to officers arresting more and more easy targets just to boost government figures. Rather like my previous post, it is easy for the government to get headline grabbing figures like - "Police arrest more criminals under Labour" - but that is not the point. What are they arresting people for is more relevant.